I find the proliferation of undergrad transfers to be unfortunate, but that is reality, and has been for several years. High school kids sometimes make college decisions that end up not being the right fit. Sometimes coaches get recruits that are not the right fit. The average college freshman retention rate is about 72%. Average six year graduation rate is in the mid-sixty percent.
Relative to grad transfers, there have been many comments about why that is okay that I agree with. Holyfield gets his SFASU diploma today. He has a desire to make playing basketball his career. He has a chance to further his growth and development toward that in a different setting, with different approaches. What a great opportunity for the young man. And, he gets to further his formal education at the same time. And, he gets to do it closer to home. I know you disagree, and that is fine, but he will always be a Lumberjack to me. TJ and I are both SFA alumni.
If I have a head coach that, while conducting the program morally and ethically, does not fully utilize the rules in place to build a winning program, he won't be my head coach very long. I don't like the one and done rule, and hope that gets changed. However, I don't dislike Calipari because he fully utilized that rule to win. (I may dislike him for other reasons, but that is a different story.)